Bing and Danny have wonderful back and forth together, so I very much enjoy their repartee, it's pretty much Rosemary and Vera-Ellen that stretch my credulity. For one thing, it's hard to imagine them as sisters as they look absolutely nothing alike. For another, the chemistry that they have with the boys is a little hard to believe. This is especially true in the second to third act transition when Rosemary takes some miscommunicated gossip to heart and plays the spurned lover, running off to New York and dropping Bing flat. Romances in films like this are never really evocative or believable anyway, merely plot contrivances to keep the thin stories going and provide ample opportunity for conflict, but it still takes me out the movie.
Still, for all of its faults, White Christmas has plenty to like about it. The duet that Bing and Rosemary have in the second act ("Counting Your Blessings"), not to mention the final number that gives reprise to the battlefield campfire routine of the cold open, good stuff there. I also must admit that Vera-Ellen is a heckuva dancer, even if her voice work was done by Rosemary. There's quite a bit of cheese and schmaltz, but it's the warm kind, with even the somewhat risque jokes exuding the quiet cool that isn't quite Rat Pack but almost there.
On the whole, White Christmas will remain both in my Instant Queue and on my shelf as one of those annual Christmas tradition films in spite of its obvious, glaring flaws. Bing, Danny, Rosemary, and Vera-Ellen have just enough oomph to push past their era's culturally insensitive idioms and deliver quite a few quality performances... I just wish the non-holiday routines had been shelved or kept in actual variety revues like That's Entertainment.
Until tomorrow, Potatoes~